Description:
This classic whaling bar housed in an early-19th-century brick building in the center of town is a Nantucket institution, though a recent renovation after a fire removed a lot of its former charm. In July and August, tourists line up for a table in the dark tavern downstairs to chow on burgers and hand-cut curly fries. An elaborate renovation added an upstairs dining room; there is also seating outside on a raised terrace. In the fall and winter, locals sit beside the cozy brick hearth to enjoy decently priced dinner offerings like chicken teriyaki and fried Cajun shrimp. This place serves food later than anywhere else in town; you can order off the late-night menu 'til midnight.
- © Frommer's 2013
-
Ask a local about Brotherhood of Thieves
Locals have answered 1 question about Nantucket.
Ask Nantucket Locals about Brotherhood of Thieves
User Reviews for Brotherhood of Thieves
-
Excellent food
-
Love the food! Steak and cheese sub with great fries and a huge platter of nachos which were to brag about. Initial hesitation to go in because it was a dark place on a sunny day but...
-
Read full
review
on
TripAdvisor
- posted on 11.20.12
- by Susan C
-
A real "Pirates" den
-
Since we were vacationing in Nantucket during the month of October, most eating establishments were closed up for the season. Fortunately we found The Brotherhood of Thieves to wet...
-
Read full
review
on
TripAdvisor
- posted on 11.14.12
- by sunneegirl
-
Awesome lunch!
-
A few different locals recommended lunch at the Brotherhood and we were not disappointed. The flatbread with scallops and bacon was light and delicious. Great burgers, salads and beef...
-
Read full
review
on
TripAdvisor
- posted on 11.10.12
- by Pcboca85
Awards:
Frommer's
- Recommended 2010
- Details
-
Contact:
- visit website
- tel: +1 508 228 2551
- fax: +1 508 228 6168
Address:
- 23 Broad St
- Nantucket, MA 02554
Neighborhood:
Nantucket TownPayments:
-
Hours:
- Mar-Jan Mon-Sat 11:30am-midnight, Sun noon-10pm
- User Rating
